Bishop Minerva G. Carcaño offers conference update on the Boy Scouts case and asks for healing prayers for the victims

December 22, 2021

Bishop Minerva G. Carcaño offers conference update on the Boy Scouts case and asks for healing prayers for the victims

Brothers and Sisters, Siblings, as you know The United Methodist Church has been involved in the Boy Scouts’ Bankruptcy Case. Our denomination has had a long-standing commitment to scouting, and this legal process has been difficult and concerning. We have been most concerned about the victims whose suffering this bankruptcy case is seeking to address.

Pending further legal proceedings, those leading us in this very serious matter have reached a settlement. The following public statement from our United Methodist Communications Office of Public Information lays out the specifics of the settlement.

While there is still work to be done, I want to take this moment to ask that we continue to pray for the victims, for our congregations, and those who have labored long on this matter and will continue to work on our behalf as United Methodists. I am grateful for the leadership of our Conference Chancellor, Jay Rosenlieb, who led our denominational efforts on this matter until recently. Our District Superintendents have been diligent in assisting our local churches most directly affected by this legal matter through the charge conference processes that have been required of them. They are working on this even now. Our Council on Finance and Administration and Executive Director of Finance and Administration have assisted with the financial support necessary for this connectional work and will be asked with our Board of Trustees to lead us in addressing further financial requests that will be forthcoming to each Conference. Above all, gratitude needs to be expressed to our local churches who are striving to be places of safety and care for young people.

Blessings of peace and healing to all.

Official Press Release of The UMC, December 21, 2021:

United Methodists reach settlement in Boy Scouts’ Bankruptcy Case

United Methodist leaders have reached a settlement in the matter of the Boy Scouts of America’s (BSA) pending bankruptcy proceedings. Upon final court approval, the settlement would absolve any claims of sexual abuse that may have occurred in congregation-sponsored Scouting programs.

Under the terms of the settlement, United Methodists would raise and give $30 million over a three-year period into a fund that will be utilized to compensate survivors, and United Methodist congregations that charter Scout troops and packs would be released from all abuse claims involving Scouting activities. A team has been formed to identify strategies and materials that may be used to raise the funds. The church would also agree to work for the healing of survivors and recommit to work toward ending sexual abuse of young people. Through the General Commission on United Methodist

Men, United Methodists will work with the BSA to continue to ensure Scout safety and grow Scouting ministry as part of its mandate through The Book of Discipline.

“We are sorry for what occurred and are praying for all those who experienced harm through Scouting activities. We are committed to the protection of children and youth, and the United Methodist Council of Bishops will be working with the church, the Survivor Working Group and BSA to address policies, programs, and procedures in order to keep Scouts safe from abuse,” said Bishop John Schol, chair of the UMC leadership team created to support the United Methodist chartering organizations in the bankruptcy matter.

The settlement follows months of mediation by an Ad Hoc committee of bishops, chancellors and general agency employees that has been advocating for United Methodist interests.

“I want to thank everyone who has been working through the mediation process for the healing and just resolution of the survivors,” said Schol. “Our settlement agreement has the support of both the BSA and the Coalition of Abused Scouts for Justice.”

The United Methodist Church has long worked proactively to prevent child abuse. The percentage of claims in the last 20 years potentially related to United Methodist congregations’-sponsored scouting units is less than 1 percent of all UMC claims.

Under the terms of the agreement, denomination leaders will intensify efforts to prevent and raise awareness of child sexual abuse.

The Council of Bishops of The United Methodist Church has committed to lead the church in carrying out the following:

· Work with all United Methodists to raise funds for the Survivor Trust Fund.

· Tell the story of harm done to survivors through a series of articles to be published by the denomination and by each U.S. annual conference to draw attention to child sexual abuse and call upon the church to be vigilant in working to prevent child sexual abuse in churches, homes and the community.

· Carry out a denomination-wide review of all Safe Sanctuaries and other policies to safeguard young people from sexual abuse and update policies as necessary and ensure the policies are being followed.

· Provide opportunities for sexual abuse survivors to share their experiences with United Methodist leadership if they choose to do so.

· Work with all United Methodist ministries and with the Boy Scouts of America to continue to make programs safe for all young people.

· Provide leadership to help all BSA chartering organizations to make a $100 million contribution to the Survivor Trust Fund.

· Participate as a member of the Survivors Working Group


The Ad Hoc Committee recommends that churches who filed a proof of claim vote “yes” on the plan and for those who previously voted “no,” the Ad Hoc Committee recommends congregations change their vote to “yes.” An email from conference leadership will be sent to churches that filed a proof of claim on how to vote “yes” and how to change a vote from “no” to “yes.”


Media contact: Diane Degnan 615.742.5406


California-Nevada Conference
1350 Halyard Drive
West Sacramento, CA 95691
(916) 374-1500